Crispin Sartwell: Truth is real

Taken together, the continental and analytic meltdowns indicate that truth is either an evil authoritarian force or that it is nothing at all. That just about does it, doesn’t it? In one way or the other, then, and through the whole century, truth seemed to be in collapse, a scene of puzzlement and despair, a land from which philosophers had emigrated. But we haven’t stopped needing to figure out what’s true, or stopped arguing about it as though we know what we mean. Questions about what is true are, putting it mildly, no less urgent now than they were in 1900. Truth, that is, has proven as hard to eradicate as it is to elucidate. We keep finding we need the notion…

It is often said, rather casually, that truth is dissolving, that we live in the ‘post-truth era’. But truth is one of our central concepts – perhaps our most central concept – and I don’t think we can do without it. To believe that masks prevent the spread of COVID-19 is to take it to be true that they do. To assert it is to claim that it is true. Truth is, plausibly, central to thought and communication in every case. And, of course, it’s often at stake in practical political debates and policy decisions, with regard to climate change or vaccines, for example, or who really won the election, or whom we should listen to about what.

One might have hoped to turn to philosophy for a clarification of the nature of truth, and maybe even a celebration of it. But philosophy of pragmatist, analytic and continental varieties lurched into the post-truth era a century ago. If truth is a problem now for everyone, if the idea seems empty or useless in ‘the era of social media’, ‘science denialism’, ‘conspiracy theories’ and suchlike, maybe that just means that ‘everyone’ has caught up to where philosophy was in 1922…

https://aeon.co/essays/truth-is-real-and-philosophers-must-return-their-attention-to-it

Jon Henley: Rise of far right puts Dreyfus affair into spotlight in French election race

Alexandre Koyré The Political Function of the Modern Lie

Richard Evans: the film Denial ‘shows there is such a thing as truth’

Keith Kahn-Harris – Denialism: what drives people to reject the truth

VENU SUNDARAM – the Curious Case of the Judges Who Wouldn’t Listen

STANISLAV MARKELOV – Patriotism as a diagnosis

Julien Benda: Our age is the age of the intellectual organization of political hatreds

Beginnings and Endings

A moment of moral and political nihilism: Theologian Adam Kotsko on our current crisis

Stanley Rosen (1929-2014). A great philosopher passes

José Vergara’s “All Future Plunges to the Past: James Joyce in Russian Literature”