Apoorva Mandhani: Judge Loya’s Confidants Died Mysterious Deaths

First posted October 22, 2019

NB: This report on the deaths of Judge Loya and his two friends appeared in 2018. Our ‘free and unfettered’ media continues to ignore this matter; as it has ignored the suicide of an ex Chief Minister who alleged high-level corruption in the judiciary; and has also failed to pursue the manner in which criminal cases involving allies of the Sangh Parivar seem to end up in favour of the accused, with no one being held responsible for heinous crimes. 

The government has protected lynchers; and covered up the death of a judge: a relative of the Maharashtra CM threatened a lawyer pursuing the matter. The Sangh and its allies have indulged in sabotage of justice: in the Bhima Koregaon case, they have misused executive power to protect their cadre. They have secured dismissal of cases in which their associates were implicated, by causing court records to disappear as in the Aseemanand  case.

There have been 67 ‘encounter‘ killings since March 2017. V. L. Solanki, the police officer who worked on the Sohrabuddin case says the government is trying to silence him: ‘If a sitting judge can die suddenly, I am just an inconsequential retired police inspector. The government and the police can go to any extent to ensure everyone accused in the case gets a clean chit. They can kill too.’ 

So much for the new policy of zero tolerance of terrorism. (Zero for some, sky is the limit for others).  So much for the justice system we may look forward to under the utopia called Hindu Rashtra. To the op-ed writers who have reduced journalism to Orwellian propaganda, I can only paraphrase (ironically) L K Advani’s comment about the behaviour of the media during the Emergency: You were asked to bend, why are you crawling? 

It is ironic because, having sown the wind of communal fanaticism, Mr Advani has been rewarded for his efforts by being placed in the “useless idiot” category of retired firebrands of the Sangh Parivar. Even PranabDa is more useful to them. But there are those who are paying a much heavier price. Judge Loya’s family and the families of his dead friends, for example. Not to mention the family of Pehlu Khan, whom no one killed. And numbers of journalists who have been forced out of their jobs for beng committed professionals. DS

Apoorva Mandhani: Judge Loya’s Confidants Died Mysterious Deaths

At a press conference held  on Wednesday, Congress leaders and Senior Advocates Kapil Sibal, Salman Khurshid and Vivek Tankha demanded an independent probe into the death of special CBI Judge B.H. Loya, raising suspicions regarding the death of two of Judge Loya’s associates as well.

Asserting that the “truth is to be investigated Loya talked of pressure and right now democracy is under threat”, Mr. Sibal explained that his interactions with a whistle-blower in the case lawyer Satish Uike revealed that Judge Loya had been handed over a “draft order” with a direction to approve it before 31 October, 2014.

Mr. Uike had been introduced to Judge Loya by Advocate Shrikant Khandalkar and retired District Judge Prakash Thombre. All three of them were then informed about and given the copies of the draft order by Judge Loya, who had sought their help in dealing with the “pressure” that he was facing to exonerate the accused in the Sohrabuddin murder case. While Mr. Thombre and Mr. Uike travelled to Delhi to seek help from a few Senior Advocates, they had returned back disheartened.

Soon after, Judge Loya officially died of a cardiac arrest on 1 December, 2014 in Nagpur, where he had gone to attend a wedding. Subsequently, both Mr. Khandalkar and Mr. Thombre died mysterious deaths, Mr. Sibal alleged, after confiding in Mr. Uike regarding the threats that they were receiving from Nagpur.

He alleged that while Mr. Khandalkar was “pushed” from the 8th floor of a District Court building in November, 2015, Mr. Thombre passed away during a train journey in May, 2016. Mr. Uike was also threatened, he said, when around 5,000 kilograms of iron fell on the roof of his office barely moments after he had exited. The Congress leaders also narrated the incidents that led to Judge Loya’s death, especially highlighting the fact that his security was withdrawn from 20 November, 2014 to 2 December, 2014. Noting that the reason given for this was that his security officer was unwell, Mr. Sibal questioned the absence of alternative officers for providing security to Judge Loya.

Mr. Sibal also put on record the register of the VIP guest house where Judge Loya reportedly stayed during his visit in Nagpur. The register, he said, neither contained Judge Loya’s name nor Judge Shriram Modak’s name, who he allegedly stayed with. Mr. Uike, who was present at the conference, referred to Judge Loya’s post-mortem report to claim that it had been tampered with as the papers showed that the doctor conducted two post-mortems at the same time. Judge Loya’s ‘viscera forwarding form’ was also repeatedly referred to, to highlight such discrepancies.

Mr. Sibal, then, raised questions such as, “Why was Judge J.T. Utpal, Judge Loya’s predecessor in Sohrabuddin Fake encounter case transferred from hearing the case despite Supreme Court order specifying that the same Judge will hear the matter from start to finish?… Why didn’t Bombay High Court lodge an FIR when Judge Loya’s sister alleged that Justice Mohit Shah offered him a bribe of Rs. 100 crore?… Why didn’t the judiciary take up the matter? Who was being saved and why?”

With such suspicions, he appealed for an investigation by an independent SIT, which should not contain any CBI or NIA officer. In the absence of such investigation, he said, the party would “go to every village to tell them about the injustice being meted out”. The democracy, he said, is in “peril”, referring to the press conference held by the four sitting Supreme Court Judges.

The Caravan report: The conference comes at a time when the Supreme Court is hearing two petitions demanding an independent probe into Judge Loya’s death. The allegations first appeared in two reports by The Caravan Magazine, which cited interviews with Judge Loya’s relatives: his sister Anuradha Biyani, niece Nupur Balaprasad Biyani and father Harkishan. According to the magazine, Judge Loya’s wife Sharmila and son Anuj declined to speak since they feared for their lives.

As per the article, Judge Loya was in Nagpur for the 30 November, 2014 wedding of the daughter of another sitting Judge at the Mumbai Sessions Court, Swapna Joshi. On 1 December, his family members received calls informing them about his demise after suffering a massive cardiac arrest.

The investigative report by Mr. Niranjan Takle points out glaring inconsistencies in the cardiac arrest story. It highlights inconsistencies in the reported account of the death. There were large variations in the precise time of his death and that fact that Judge Loya’s phone was wiped clean of all data before it was returned to the family. The Judge’s postmortem report was also allegedly signed by maiyatacha chulatbhau, or paternal cousin, when his family says there is no such person in the family. Further, his family members had noticed blood on his clothes.

Another article had alleged that Justice Mohit Shah had offered Judge Loya Rs. 100 crore for a judgment in favor of Mr. Amit Shah. The article had quote the Judge’s sister, who claimed that Justice Shah would would call him late at night to meet in civil dress and pressure him to issue the judgment as soon as possible and to ensure that it is a positive judgment. “My brother was offered a bribe of 100 crore in return for a favorable judgment. Mohit Shah, the chief justice, made the offer himself.”

Shortly after Judge Loya’s death, a new Judge, M.B. Gosavi had discharged Mr. Amit Shah, after hearing the parties for three days. The article goes on to question the manner in which the trial took place, asserting that it had violated a September 2012 Supreme Court order, that the Sohrabuddin trial should be conducted from beginning to end by the same officer.


Rahul Gandhi Case : Gujrat से जुड़े बड़ी प्लानिंग के तार, सच आएगा सामने | Justice Loya

Death of Judge Loya: A critical examination of the ECG and post-mortem demonstrates the failings of the SC verdict

A Family Breaks Its Silence: Shocking Details Emerge In death of presiding judge in Sohrabuddin Trial

Book Review: ‘Who Killed Justice Loya’ Delves into Many Unanswered Questions

The Lady Vanishes

Gandhi’s Assassin. By Dhirendra K Jha

How Savarkar Escaped Conviction for Gandhi’s Assassination