Modi’s McCarthyism and the politics of invisible enemies / The election before the election in UP

Bharat Bhushan

Like Joseph McCarthy, Narendra Modi is using the language of national security and loyalty to not only narrow the space for dissent, but also to taint it with criminal intent

Prime Minister Narendra Modi’s speech in Bastar to CRPF personnel marks an important transformation of his public narrative. After taking credit for lifting 50 crore people out of poverty and ending the Naxalite insurgency, he claimed that ideological Naxalism was still very much alive. These “Dimagi Naxals”, he claimed, had infiltrated political parties and other organisations, and needed to be identified and defeated.

He told the paramilitary assembly, “Armed Naxalites have vanished from the forests, but intellectual Naxalites have captured many organisations. Even today, they are provoking people against the Constitution and democracy of the country. These intellectual Naxalites have also infiltrated several political parties and various organisations. We must identify them, defeat them, and secure the nation.” The impropriety of the speech and the context in which it was made both need to be understood.

Modi’s spoke attired in security-style camouflage that deliberately blurred the distinction between civilian executive authority and India’s neutral security apparatus. Although paramilitary forces should not be drawn into the partisan politics of a particular government in power, Modi was asking the CRPF to share his political definition of what constitutes a continuing Naxalite threat. It is not without significance that the framing of political dissent as another form of Naxalism took place in Bastar, the CRPF’s battleground against Naxalite insurgency.

Modi’s efforts to draw the CRPF to his side of the political battlelines is not accidental at all.

He is still shaken by the results of the 2024 general elections when voters denied him a clear majority. Then, this July his image took a massive beating in the student agitation with Gen-Z taking him down on social media in unprecedentedly sharp personal attacks, bordering on the profane. He had to concede to their demand of sacking his education minister.

Immediately after, the Opposition took him on over the subversion of constitutional institutions, the Election Commission of India, ‘vote-theft’ through voter deletions and allegations of democratic backsliding. In this context, Dimagi Naxals has come as a handy term to label his critics — both from parties of the Opposition and from civil society. Refusing to reply to their accusations, Modi, his ministers, and the ruling Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP) have accused them of spreading anarchy and operating as instruments of foreign powers.

Dimagi Naxal is not defined by law and, therefore, not an offence. But since Modi makes no distinction between Naxalites engaged in unlawful and violent acts and those who express disagreement with the government, the new name for the national enemy is left open to political interpretation.

Modi desperately needs to reinvent himself given the erosion in mass acceptance. As in earlier moments of crises, he has reached once again for the rhetoric of national security. He wants the ongoing political contestations in India not to be seen as demands for better and more accountable governance, but as a struggle between patriots and internal enemies, now dressed up as Naxalites. This allows him to present the security agenda as an unfinished one where the active presence of imagined enemies requires his watchful leadership.

Modi’s political language echoes that of United States Senator Joseph McCarthy who rose to political prominence in the early 1950s by exploiting the fear of Communist sympathisers having infiltrated US society. As in McCarthy’s case, the argument runs that victory over one set of Communists has not ended the battle but requires a sustained rooting out of those who are ostensibly hiding in the interstices of politics, culture, and civil society.

Modi’s creation of imaginary, nebulous, and undefinable enemies has been a slow movement from ‘Tukde-Tukde gang’, ‘Urban Naxals’, ‘Andolanjeevis’, and agents of foreign conspiracy to ‘Dimagi Naxals’. At each stage the definition becomes progressively broader to include more of those who influence public opinion, teach in universities, and actors and comedians — those who are political party workers or are active in civil society organisations.

Potentially, this is an ever-expanding category of enemies. It gives the BJP cadre an evolving adversary against whom they can rally. And, without having to answer any criticism of the government, it tries to put those protesting its policies and attack on democratic institutions on the defensive, requiring them to prove their nationalist credentials.

Like McCarthy, Modi is using the language of national security and loyalty to not only narrow the space for dissent, but also to taint it with criminal intent. McCarthyism in the US did not limit itself to the persecution of alleged Communists in government. It extended to Hollywood actors, screenwriters, academics, journalists, and intellectuals, who were blacklisted and professionally destroyed.

There may not be a formal government blacklist in India, and the conditions are very different from what they were in the US during the 1950’s Cold War. However, political intimidation, institutional pressure, and communal mobilisation exist on the ground. Academics and social activists have been branded urban Naxals; journalists have been raided and persecuted; comedians and Bollywood actors have faced organised boycotts, and Muslim cultural figures have had their nationalism questioned.

Modi’s call to identify and defeat ideological dissenters aims to suppress the mass energy that has just begun to bubble up in the public sphere. The enemy is no longer just the Maoist insurgent but can be anyone in a political party, official institution, and civil society organisation whom the government considers hostile.

This converts every citizen into a potential suspect, making people wary of speaking out, others from defending them, and political parties from challenging the government in power.

Political parties and civil society, therefore, need to fight the idea that dissent in democracy somehow means disloyalty. This requires rejecting Modi’s vocabulary and demanding material evidence in Parliament for the allegations of foreign conspiracy and conspiracy to create anarchy.

The Opposition should ask which organisations have been infiltrated, who is responsible, which minister is responsible, what illegal activities have been committed, and by whom. The Opposition must also take this to ordinary people — defending the right of workers to organise, students to protest, farmers to demonstrate, journalists to investigate, and citizens to seek accountability.

Civil society, meanwhile, needs to form broad, non-partisan coalitions for defending civil liberties — defending freedom of speech, association, and peaceful assembly. The constitutional right to question cannot be reduced to a concession granted or withdrawn by the Narendra Modi government.

https://www.deccanherald.com/opinion/modis-mccarthyism-and-the-politics-of-invisible-enemies-4216903

*************

The Election Before The Election In Uttar Pradesh